Coca-Cola isn't following Pepsi into dropping aspartame, should you?

By Frazer Jones
Last month, PepsiCo announced major changes coming to its Diet Pepsi formula. The global snacks and soft drinks business reported that, starting later o...

Last month, PepsiCo announced major changes coming to its Diet Pepsi formula. The global snacks and soft drinks business reported that, starting later on in 2015, Diet Pepsi would be swapping out the aspartame sweetener in Diet Pepsi, Caffeine Free Diet Pepsi, and Wild Cherry Diet Pepsi with a blend of sucralose and acesulfame potassium. (Think: Splenda.) Now Coca-Cola has released a statement of its own—confirming that it will not be changing the classic formula for lead Diet Pepsi rival Diet Coke.

Aspartame in general has been falling out of favor for some time now, with more natural sweeteners like sucralose and stevia gaining popularity in its place. But Coca-Cola’s reasoning for sticking with aspartame is also fairly compelling—why fix what isn’t broken? Essentially as long as consumers are happy with the taste of Diet Coke that they’re used to, Coca-Cola sees no need to mess with a winning formula:

“Our view is that Diet Coke’s principle equity is great taste,” said Sandy Douglas, president of Coca-Cola North America. “We’re going to be very careful before we change the taste of it. We follow the consumer. The consumer’s telling us, ‘don’t change Diet Coke; we love it just the way it is,’ but at the same time there is a lot of junk science and alarmism around low- and no-calorie sweeteners that we have to address, and most importantly we have to ask third parties to help us address it because in the end low- or no-calorie sweeteners are 100% safe. We would never sell an ingredient in one of our products that wasn’t safe.”


That’s something that any executive in the soft drink industry—or any sector considering making a change in the name of health—needs to think about and weigh carefully. Would a change in formula change the taste of your product? If so, how would that change affect your relationship with consumers? Further down on the Top 10 list of highest selling soft drinks, Diet Pepsi has more to gain by tweaking its formula for higher consumer appeal. But Diet Coke is already almost at the top of the list—in this case, changing its formula could do more harm than good to its sales.

It’s a tough choice, and as sales of traditional soft drinks continue to decline overall, making the right choice can be the difference between sinking and swimming in the industry. What would you choose?  



Featured Articles

Unilever CEO Schumacher Lays out Plastics Roadmap

Unilever CEO Hein Schumacher sets out a roadmap to a Global Plastics Treaty, in wake of controversy that saw company criticised for watering down ESG goals

Ahold Delhaize Targets Sustainability & Omnichannel Goals

Multinational food business Ahold Delhaize prioritises sustainability and omnichannel innovation as part of its new plan for financial and strategic goals

US Bird flu Turns Spotlight on Milk Pasteurisation

As bird flu sees sales of raw milk spike, we look at the work of Tetra Pak, a giant in the world of pasteurisation.

Nestlé 'Meeting Sustainability Targets on Nescafé Coffee'


Coffee Prices Soar as Extreme Weather Hits Brazil & Vietnam


Guinness & Carlsberg Back Drought Resistant Grain for Beer